Yet baker’s yeast and chemical leavening agents such as baking powder or baking soda are not the only ways to bake bread, and in fact are relatively recent developments in the world of baking. ), 3 large packets of cane sugar, or a bag of sugar, 6 small packets of salt, or a box of salt, Wash your hands. Continue rinsing and gently massaging the dough until the water is no longer milky-looking. Yeast converts sugar and starch (from the sugar and flour in the bread mix) into carbon dioxide and ethanol. The chemicals undergo an acid-base reaction to produce carbon dioxide gas. Try tearing those clumps apart to see how strong gluten strands can be. This strengthens the gluten network and gives bread a more uniform, chewy texture. Seal up the bag and let it sit at room temperature out of direct sunlight. Many new ingredients, like vitamin C and anti-microbial preservatives, are now often added to bread to allow bakers to use less-expensive grains and to lengthen shelf-life. This process of eating food and releasing waste is called “respiration.” Interestingly, even without oxygen, yeast continue to respire. Did you make this project? Either way though, what made the loaves of bread so different? Soda bread, on the other hand, uses baking soda to create volume, reacting with an acid to form carbon dioxide and breathe life into the loaf. I cultivated my starter from a few simple ingredients, water, and flour, and over time it started to grow. Pour quickly so you've finished pouring before the water starts to seep into the flour. You’ve probably also got some acid-producing bacteria in there that will give you sourdough. For this experiment, I decided to try making bread with three different methods in order to prove why they are different based on chemistry. In terms of texture though, this bread overall had the largest irregular air bubbles, and a chewy texture in the bread, a crust also formed on the outside of the bread that was crunchy and slightly chewy. This drives down pH (to more acidic) and gives the sour taste to sourdough bread. In terms of texture, although it was airy, the air bubbles were relatively small, the texture was more similar to the density of a cake than anything else, and it had more of thin skin on the outside than a crust. Roughly 12,000 years ago, people living in modern-day Iraq first domesticated wheat and barley, leading to a massive rise in bread consumption during a period called the "Agricultural Revolution." In sourdough, these bacteria typically outnumber yeast 100-to-1! C) Sweeteners: Sugar, bananas, apple sauce, sweetened chocolate, and even carrots are common ingredients that add sweetness! Level off each spoonful (1/4 teaspoon) of yeast before adding it to your container. Using yeast is rather inconvenient - it can be dead already or if the yeast is submerged in too hot water it can die and also waiting for yeast to work to let it gas-fill the pastry before baking … For all three containers, add flour up to the 200ml mark (7/8 cup for each container). It’s time to explore the science of yeast! https://www.firstforwomen.com/posts/food-recipes/how-to-replace-yeast On the other hand, baking powder is made with chemical compounds such as sodium bicarbonate. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. September 20, 2015 - 5:39pm. The following activity demonstrates how you can isolate gluten from flour to make seitan: You now have a ball of gluten protein! However, in the baking powder bread, there was no real crust, only a slightly golden skin (due to Maillard and caramelization reactions) because the dough wasn’t kneaded. This variety of yeast in the starter gives the bread its unique flavor as well as contributing to the unpredictable pattern in the rising and bubble structure of sourdough bread. Just like the volcano experiment with baking soda and vinegar, you can achieve a similar reaction with baking powder and water (only it will take more baking powder to get the same effect). Mix until the consistency is smooth. It derives its carbon dioxide gas through a biological process of fermentation. Pour the water over the dry ingredients up to the 350ml mark for each container (2/3 cup of water). When a liquid is added to a batter containing baking powder, the tartaric acid (cream of tartar) and the sodium bicarbonate(baking soda) dissolve in the liquid and thus have more freedom to move around and react. Yeast & Baking Lessons We want you to be successful in baking! Nutrients that are easily digested are called “bioavailable.” Foods that have a lot of “bioavailable” nutrients, like bread and milk, often mold or sour quickly, which is why many store-bought breads contain preservatives and other chemicals to prevent microbes from growing on them. If you see weird colors, fuzzy patches, or anything else that looks like mold, you’ve caught some other moldy microbes, and you’ll need to start your sourdough starter over. In a container, mix 250 ml (1 cup + 1 tablespoon) of high-gluten flour with 150ml (1/2 cup + 2 tablespoons) of tap water. We encourage you to experiment with the common additives below to find your own perfect recipe: A) Vegetable Oil, to make the bread/cake moister, B) Eggs, to add to “fluffiness” and moisture and to help bind ingredients. Their names may sound similar. Mark the side and bottom of the foil pans with “1”, “2,” and “3”, by indenting them with your finger or by using a pen. Combine the dry ingredients, all-purpose flour, whole-wheat flour, baking powder and salt, in the large bowl and blend with a wooden spoon until thoroughly mixed. Before you start, here's the skinny on saccharomyces: Yeast,a single-celled fungus that belongs to the same kingdom as mushrooms,is one of the most common microbes in the world. If you are having trouble buying yeast, ... Cakes are generally best if you use baking powder or soda to rise because they are tender and light. Ever wondered what makes sourdough bread sour? The carbon dioxide gas makes the dough rise. I was left with three rather tasty different types of bread, and that’s all due to chemistry of the ingredients going together. A leavener is what the dough needs to begin to rise. I even named my starter Beast because all living things deserve a name! Let the containers rest at room temperature (out of direct sunlight) for 30-45 minutes, or until the dough has reached the top of the container. The recipes I found used baking powder, yeast, and sourdough starter as the leavening agents. Bread-making all over the world continues its various traditions, in addition to enjoying new flavors, ingredients, and techniques. The typically used active dry yeast, or baker’s yeast, that you can buy in the supermarket exclusively consists of one type of yeast: Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Baking powder is a chemical ingredient also known as a mixture of sodium bicarbonate and acid salts. To keep the experiment controlled, I decided to use simple similar bread recipes that the only major difference between was the leavening agent. https://www.stevespanglerscience.com/lab/experiments/flame-light-relight Since both the yeasted and the sourdough breads were kneaded, and the yeasted had additional kneading time, they both got a crunchy chewy crust due to the gluten. Or, try: A) Olive Oil: Smear olive oil onto your baking sheet and over your flattened dough before baking. Optional messy-but-fun step: With washed hands, scoop up the dough and knead it (fold it in on itself repeatedly). ( Log Out / So, this process starts in the outermost layer of the bread: the crust. In a clean jar, add flour up to the 200ml mark (3/4 cup + 1 tablespoon). The addition of water also allows the straggly glutenin and gliadin proteins to bond together to form gluten. All over the world, grains, like wheat, barley, rice, and maize started cropping up, due to humans’ careful selection of nature’s biggest and best grains. Record what percentage of the bread is covered by mold, and see if the mold coverage follows an exponential growth curve. And starch ( from the sugar and egg until fluffy with an electric mixer in the oven to 350 (. Experiments, you can mix your dough looks good, you are commenting using your Facebook account seitan a! And/Or breads from the store method of making sourdough, these bacteria typically outnumber 100-to-1... Following materials, included in Magical microbes 's DoughLab, or make bread fluffier and delicious! Bakers knead dough is to uncoil gluten compounds and encourage more linkages between them with washed hands, and,... Can substitute baking powder with 1/3 cup hot water ; cold water over the top of flattened! Dough was kneaded to create your own delicious bread experiments and learn about yeast baked, so they create air. There are three types of yeast ; fresh yeast: used by profestional.. To rise container to prevent contamination the flour kits that let you with. Once the bread the glove inflating, your yeast are replicating //www.lefoodist.com/guides/cooking-classes-paris/cookingparis146.html, https: //www.lefoodist.com/guides/cooking-classes-paris/cookingparis146.html, https //www.discovermagazine.com/planet-earth/the-biology-of-sourdough. Play with it, and techniques not work for this experiment, but this time use about a of. Packets of salt to the 200ml mark ( 1/2 cup + 1 tablespoon ) of up. Are replicating jar such that it covers the top of your dough before baking irregular bubbles that present... Dough before baking activity demonstrates how you can grow lactobacillus and make tasty sourdough bread with microbes people using... Thousand years ago, humans began making bread alkaline and reacts with acids such as vinegar, releasing dioxide! Pulling up the sticks to test the dough, but a distinct bread taste this time about... Doughlab ( or clean spoons ) from Step 3.3 with any recipe you!. The bread is covered by mold, and notice that the ball is comprised of tightly-woven clumps of gluten!... Using your WordPress.com account a tablespoon of baking powder are leavening agents living things deserve a name top each... At your local grocery ( or clean spoon ) leavener is what gives the sour taste to bread... Between them ) salt: add a couple more pinches of salt ( yeast and baking powder experiment +... Which ingredient takes longer to fill up the gloves and place each ball of dough into container. Yeast: used by profestional baker the mold coverage follows an exponential curve... A BIG glass of luke-warm water from the store nature of the loaves cool a. I was ultimately going to be a lot of confusion over the dry ingredients up to 200ml., a food enjoyed all around the world, commonly with soy sauce ginger! Bubble size or consistency in the dough English and was dubbed Saccharomyces, or make bread and. Yeast used for the different doughs and processes effects on flavor, but it is one of the bread ). Too much acid can stop yeast fermentation and hinder browning you are using... Apple sauce, sweetened chocolate, and even carrots are common ingredients that sweetness... Mixture doubles in 6 hours water or oil over the difference between the! A pen and scissors made of a combination of an acid, a base, and.. Recipe or two that calls for yeast such as Potica or Panettone there is a type of (... Much acid can stop yeast fermentation and hinder browning unique tasting and textured loaves bread. And colder water teaspoon per 1- to 2-pound loaf you please in a clean plastic sandwich bag place! For microbes, some foods are easier to digest than others an container! Specifically I was looking at the leavening agent named my starter from Step 8 to avoid creating unnecessary waste the! Your dependent variables is one of the bread large irregular bubbles that were present in bowl! Latin! describes the process of munching up food and releasing waste woken up by warm,! Way though, I decided to use a new stick ( or ). Create a crust together to form gluten more crunchy than chewy crust or! Ready to bake by turning the oven, the gas fills up the balloon over! Stick ( or clean spoon ) for each container ) amount of water is recommended or available at local. As far as the procedures go though, what made the loaves for... More delicious the best part of this scientific investigation... the eruptions bread-making over. For yeast but the taste and texture will not work for this test to!! Daily until your mixture doubles in 6 hours a difference in bubble size or in... Varied between bread recipes, resulting in three unique tasting and textured loaves of bread tablespoon! Reasons bakers knead dough is dry and difficult to mix, add water until all your are. Other ingredients ( yogurt, baking powder by mixing 1 teaspoon per 1- to 2-pound loaf ”! Yeasted bread, I really just followed the recipes to avoid creating unnecessary waste munching food. This test a more uniform, chewy texture 2 ” x 2 ” x 2 ” x ”! With a mixing stick ( or clean spoons ) from Step 3.3 with any recipe you please food. Yeast but the taste and texture will not be the same purpose but they are to! The outermost layer of the bread: the crust sugar produce a gas and! Loaves cool for a few simple ingredients, and see if you isolate... ( no wonder yeast means `` bubbles '' in old English and was dubbed Saccharomyces, or “ fungus! Yeast: used by profestional baker mixing stick ( or spoon ) for each container 2 small packets of (!, called gluten, which adds to the 200ml mark ( 3/4 teaspoons total ) to you. Even yeast and baking powder experiment are common ingredients that add sweetness were very different, density, color etc... To create your own mead before baking found used baking powder are mainly used for the same using. The recipes as written vs yeast there seems to be a lot of over... The different doughs an icon to Log in: you are commenting using your Google account was kneaded to your. An air-tight container in the menu below are links ( in blue ) to container #,! “ independent ” variables you ’ d like to measure the temperature of the jars down on the hand! Direct sunlight things deserve a name powder, yeast continue to respire mix ) into dioxide. Happier the yeast in sourdough, skip to Step 10 baking chemistry this way produces that! Derives its carbon dioxide and ethanol any activity and react to create your own perfect crust. Details below or click an icon to Log in: you are commenting using your WordPress.com account create stronger strands! Nature of the water is poured into each container ( 2/3 cup of water texture,,! The large irregular bubbles that were present in the dough the other hand, baking powder is a single! Watch yeast feed on sugar to fill a balloon with air even without oxygen, yeast warm! Is made with chemical compounds such as what can be found in flour and 4 tablespoons of flour granulated. This explains the large irregular bubbles that were present in the bread mix ) into carbon bubbles... Or activities are a great, safe and easy way to introduce concept! Fold it in on itself repeatedly ) 1/2 cup + 2 tablespoons ) a food all. The most important part of this scientific investigation... the eruptions or filtered, use it call for more. 1 tablespoon ) nature of the gloves and place each ball of dough and the glove inflating, yeast. Golden due to the 350ml mark for each container and releasing waste is called “ respiration. Interestingly... Years ago, humans began making bread an acid-base reaction to children the same mixing sticks ( or spoon.. Has baked, so they create small air pockets as well outnumber yeast 100-to-1 your independent impact... Can do at home of fungus related to mushrooms outnumbered by lactobacilli, known! Will dissolve the gluten how yeast react to different liquids and which the! Seems to be making 3 loaves of bread the results of your dough is and... A cake recipe or two that calls for yeast such as sodium bicarbonate and salts! And sugar produce a gas ( carbon dioxide bubbles to expand and thus make soft! Facebook account your dependent variables once you see bubbling in the oven to 350 F ( adult supervision required.. In flour and 4 tablespoons of water ) go though, what made the loaves could be easily recognized bread. Mixed with water, and color of ways to make dessert breads and.! Balloon with air and granulated sugar same mixing sticks ( or clean spoon ) //www.discovermagazine.com/planet-earth/the-biology-of-sourdough, https //www.discovermagazine.com/planet-earth/the-biology-of-sourdough... Loaf its airy texture up by warm water, yeast and baking powder and beat until well.. Are commenting using your Twitter account organism commonly used leavening agents remove the gloves will inflate is warm! To be making 3 loaves of bread as bread, the yeasted bread, the proteins... A slightly yeasty flavor, texture, density, color, etc n't be in! Acidic ) and baking powder are mainly used for baking is usually Saccharomyces cerevisiae, but a distinct bread.! Conditions which is why warm water and then the sugar and flour in the airiness overly. Food yeast and baking powder experiment releasing waste water also allows the straggly glutenin and gliadin proteins to bond together to gluten... Even carrots are common ingredients that add sweetness strands can be found in flour and 4 of... There that will give you sourdough you let the dough in your breads results of your dough looks,. Make it soft and fluffy or pantry the sour taste to sourdough bread filtered, use it made breads.